Research Papers: Design Theory and Methodology

Experimental Study on the Associations Among Sketches Based on Design Cognition

[+] Author and Article Information
Ping Yuan

School of Manufacturing Science
and Engineering,
Sichuan University,
Sichuan 610065, China
e-mail: evenyuan@126.com

Yan Li

School of Manufacturing Science
and Engineering,
Sichuan University,
No. 24 South Section 1, Yihuan Road,
Chengdu 610065, China
e-mail: liyan@scu.edu.cn

Jian Chen

Department of Engineering,
University of Leicester,
University Road,
Leicester LE1 7RH, UK
e-mail: jc734@leicester.ac.uk

Yan Xiong

School of Manufacturing Science
and Engineering,
Sichuan University,
Sichuan 610065, China
e-mail: xy@scu.edu.cn

Longfan Liu

School of Manufacturing Science
and Engineering,
Sichuan University,
Sichuan 610065, China
e-mail: liulongfan@sina.com

1Corresponding author.

Contributed by the Design Theory and Methodology Committee of ASME for publication in the JOURNAL OF MECHANICAL DESIGN. Manuscript received January 9, 2018; final manuscript received June 15, 2018; published online July 31, 2018. Assoc. Editor: Katja Holtta-Otto.

J. Mech. Des 140(10), 101102 (Jul 31, 2018) (16 pages) Paper No: MD-18-1021; doi: 10.1115/1.4040627 History: Received January 09, 2018; Revised June 15, 2018

This study aimed to investigate the generation mechanism of pairwise associated sketches and different associated types through the experimental analysis of the cognitive processes of the designers in conceptual design process. The verbal protocol analysis (VPA) was carried out on three groups of participants (designers). The first group consisted of eight university students majoring in industrial design, the second consisted of eight university students majoring in mechanical design, and the third consisted of six product designers with degrees in industrial design and over 5 years of work experience. Their cognitive processes revealed by the think-aloud protocol and outcome sketches during a specific design task were recorded. Following a content-oriented encoding scheme, the verbal data were encoded into cognitive actions, and according to the generation sequence of the sketches, the encoding results were postprocessed for the further analysis of associated sketches. First, we identified which cognitive actions played important roles in the generation of associated sketches. Next, based on the encoding results and the analyses of all associated sketches, we found that all associations can be categorized into three types (in order from low to high association levels): shape association, behavior association, and function association. Finally, we found that the differences in major background had no significant effect on the number of associated sketches but did have some influence on the diversity of association types, the differences in experience background mainly influenced the number of associated sketches in each type of association. Meanwhile, by analyzing the key cognitive actions, we also found the advantages and disadvantages of each group in the generation of different types of associations. The findings of this study can help designers with different backgrounds to choose suitable strategies to stimulate the important actions at the right time, conceive appropriate association types, and ultimately generate diverse concept sketches with high quality.

Copyright © 2018 by ASME
Your Session has timed out. Please sign back in to continue.


Yilmaz, S. , Seifert, C. M. , and Gonzalez, R. , 2010, “ Cognitive Heuristics in Design: Instructional Strategies to Increase Creativity in Idea Generation,” Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf., 24(3), p.335–355.
Linsey, J. , Clauss, E. F. , Kurtoglu, T. , Murphy, J. T. , Wood, K. L. , and Markman, A. B. , 2011, “ An Experimental Study of Group Idea Generation Techniques: Understanding the Roles of Idea Representation and Viewing Methods,” ASME J. Mech. Des., 133(3), p. 031008. [CrossRef]
Song, S. , and Agogino, A. M. , 2004, “ Insights on Designers' Sketching Activities in New Product Design Teams,” ASME Paper No. DETC2004-57474.
Yang, M. C. , 2009, “ Observations on Concept Generation and Sketching in Engineering Design,” Res. Eng. Des., 20(1), pp. 1–11. [CrossRef]
Goel, V. , 1995, Sketches of Thought, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Rodgers, P. A. , Green, G. , and Mcgown, A. , 1999, “ Using Concept Sketches to Track Design Progress,” Des. Stud., 21(5), pp. 451–464. [CrossRef]
Abdelmohsen, S. , and Yiluen, E. , 2007, “ Tracking Design Development Through Decomposing Sketching Processes,” Digital Proceedings of the International Association of Societies of Design Research (IASDR), Kowloon, Hong Kong, Nov. 12–15. https://www.sd.polyu.edu.hk/iasdr/proceeding/papers/Tracking%20Design%20Development%20Through%20Decomposing%20Sketching%20Processes%20.pdf
Kavakli, M. , Scrivener, S. A. R. , and Ball, L. J. , 1998, “ Structure in Idea Sketching Behaviour,” Des. Stud., 19(4), pp. 485–517. [CrossRef]
Yilmaz, S. , and Seifert, C. M. , 2011, “ Creativity Through Design Heuristics: A Case Study of Expert Product Design,” Des. Stud., 32(4), pp. 384–415. [CrossRef]
Lugt, R. V. D. , 2000, “ Developing a Graphic Tool for Creative Problem Solving in Design Groups,” Des. Stud., 21(5), pp. 505–522. [CrossRef]
Do, Y. L. , Gross, M. D. , Neiman, B. , and Zimring, C. , 2000, “ Intentions in and Relations Among Design Drawings,” Des. Stud., 21(5), pp. 483–503. [CrossRef]
Sun, L. , Xiang, W. , Chai, C. , Wang, C. , and Huang, Q. , 2014, “ Creative Segment: A Descriptive Theory Applied to Computer-Aided Sketching,” Des. Stud., 35(1), pp. 54–79. [CrossRef]
Elsen, C. , Demaret, J. N. , Yang, M. C. , and Leclercq, P. , 2012, “ Sketch-Based Interfaces for Modeling and Users' Needs: Redefining Connections,” Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf., 26(3), pp. 281–301. [CrossRef]
Helmi, F. , and Khaidzir, K. A. B. , 2016, “ Analyzing the Critical Role of Sketches in the Visual Transformation of Architectural Design,” Archnet Int. J. Archit. Res., 10(2), pp. 219–229.
Bar-Eli, S. , 2013, “ Sketching Profiles: Awareness to Individual Differences in Sketching as a Means of Enhancing Design Solution Development,” Des. Stud., 34(4), pp. 472–493. [CrossRef]
Sun, L. , Xiang, W. , Cheng, Y. , Yang, Z. , and Lou, Y. , 2014, “ The Role of Sketching States in the Stimulation of Idea Generation: An Eye Movement Study,” Creativity Res. J., 26(3), pp. 305–313. [CrossRef]
Prats, M. , and Garner, S. , 2006, “ Observations on Ambiguity in Design Sketches,” Tracey (epub). http://www.lboro.ac.uk/microsites/sota/tracey/journal/ambi/images/PratsGarner.pdf
Prats, M. , Lim, S. , Jowers, I. , Garner, S. W. , and Chase, S. , 2009, “ Transforming Shape in Design: Observations From Studies of Sketching,” Des. Stud., 30(5), pp. 503–520. [CrossRef]
Stiny, G. , 1990, “ What Is a Design?,” Environ. Plann. B, 17(1), pp. 97–103. [CrossRef]
Stiny, G. , 2006, Shape: Talking About Seeing and Doing, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Yilmaz, S. , Daly, S. R. , Seifert, C. M. , and Gonzalez, R. , 2011, “ A Comparison of Cognitive Heuristics Use Between Engineers and Industrial Designers,” Forth International Conference on Design Computing and Cognition (DCC), Springer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, July 12–14, pp. 3–22.
Yilmaz, S. , and Seifert, C. M. , 2010, “ Cognitive Heuristics in Design Ideation,” 11th International Design Conference (DESIGN), Dubrovnik, Croatia, May 17–20, pp. 1007–1016. https://www.designheuristics.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/11_Design_2010.pdf
Goldschmidt, G. , 1994, “ On Visual Design Thinking: The Vis Kids of Architecture,” Des. Stud., 15(2), pp. 158–174. [CrossRef]
Suwa, M. , and Tversky, B. , 1997, “ What Do Architects and Students Perceive in Their Design Sketches? A Protocol Analysis,” Des. Stud., 18(4), pp. 385–403. [CrossRef]
Lawson, B. , 2006, How Designers Think, 4th ed., Architectural Press, London.
Schon, D. A. , and Wiggins, G. , 1992, “ Kinds of Seeing and Their Functions in Designing,” Des. Stud., 13(2), pp. 135–156. [CrossRef]
Jiao, J. R. , Simpson, T. W. , and Siddique, Z. , 2007, “ Product Family Design and Platform-Based Product Development: A State-of-the-Art Review,” J. Intell. Manuf., 18(1), pp. 5–29. [CrossRef]
Simpson, T. W. , 1998, “ A Concept Exploration Method for Product Family Design,” Ph.D. dissertation, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA. http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=
Suwa, M. , Purcell, T. , and Gero, J. S. , 1998, “ Macroscopic Analysis of Design Processes Based on a Scheme for Coding Designers' Cognitive Actions,” Des. Stud., 19(4), pp. 455–483. [CrossRef]
Suwa, M. , Gero, J. S. , and Purcell, T. , 1998, “ The Roles of Sketches in Early Conceptual Design Processes,” 20th Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society, Hilldale, NJ, pp. 1043–1048. http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=
Suwa, M. , Gero, J. , and Purcell, T. , 2000, “ Unexpected Discoveries and S-Invention of Design Requirements: Important Vehicles for a Design Process,” Des. Stud., 21(6), pp. 539–567. [CrossRef]
Coley, F. , Houseman, O. , and Roy, R. , 2007, “ An Introduction to Capturing and Understanding the Cognitive Behaviour of Design Engineers,” J. Eng. Des., 18(4), pp. 311–325. [CrossRef]
Baird, F. , 2000, “ An Ethnographic Study of Engineering Design Teams at Rolls-Royce Aerospace,” Des. Stud., 21(4), pp. 333–355. [CrossRef]
Webb, C. , 2005, “ Exploration of Sense-Making and Learning With Complexity Science: A Diary-Based Study,” Ph.D. thesis, Cranfield University, Cranfield, UK.
Coolican, H. , 2013, Research Methods and Statistics in Psychology, Psychology Press, London.
Dorst, K. , and Dijkhuis, J. , 1995, “ Comparing Paradigms for Describing Design Activity,” Des. Stud., 16(2), pp. 261–274. [CrossRef]
Purcell, T. , Gero, J. , Edwards, H. , and McNeill, T. , 1994, “ The Data in Design Protocols: The Issue of Data Coding, Data Analysis in the Development of Models of the Design Process,” Artificial Intelligence in Design'94, J. S. Gero and F. Sudweeks , eds., Kluwer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, pp. 225–252.
Ahmed, S. , Wallace, K. M. , and Blessing, L. T. M. , 2003, “ Understanding the Differences Between How Novice and Experienced Designers Approach Design Tasks,” Res. Eng. Des., 14(1), pp. 1–11. [CrossRef]
Kim, J. , and Ryu, H. , 2014, “ A Design Thinking Rationality Framework: Framing and Solving Design Problems in Early Concept Generation,” Hum.-Comput. Interact., 29(5–6), pp. 516–553. [CrossRef]
Daly, S. R. , Christian, J. L. , Yilmaz, S. , Seifert, C. M. , and Gonzalez, R. , 2012, “ Assessing Design Heuristics for Idea Generation in an Introductory Engineering Course,” Int. J. Eng. Educ., 28(2), p. 463. https://lib.dr.iastate.edu/industrialdesign_pubs/5
Akin, Ö. , and Lin, C. , 1995, “ Design Protocol Data and Novel Design Decisions,” Des. Stud., 16(2), pp. 211–236. [CrossRef]
Ericsson, K. A. , and Simon, H. A. , 1993, Protocol Analysis: Verbal Reports as Data, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
Dinar, M. , Shah, J. J. , Cagan, J. , Leifer, L. , Linsey, J. , Smith, S. M. , and Hernandez, N. V. , 2015, “ Empirical Studies of Designer Thinking: Past, Present, and Future,” ASME J. Mech. Des., 137(2), p. 021101. [CrossRef]
Menezes, A. , and Lawson, B. , 2006, “ How Designers Perceive Sketches,” Des. Stud., 27(5), pp. 571–585. [CrossRef]
Cheong, H. , Hallihan, G. M. , and Shu, L. H. , 2014, “ Design Problem Solving With Biological Analogies: A Verbal Protocol Study,” Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf., 28(1), pp. 27–47. [CrossRef]
Van Someren, M. W. , Barnard, Y. F. , and Sandberg, J. A. C. , 1994, The Think Aloud Method, Academic Press, London.
Ma, G. , Li, Y. , Xiong, Y. , and Hu, Y. , 2009, “ Creative Design Research Based on Cognitive Experiment,” Comput. Integr. Manuf. Syst., 15(4), pp. 625–632 (in Chinese).
Tang, H. H. , Lee, Y. Y. , and Gero, J. S. , 2011, “ Comparing Collaborative Co-Located and Distributed Design Processes in Digital and Traditional Sketching Environments: A Protocol Study Using the Function–Behaviour–Structure Coding Scheme,” Des. Stud., 32(1), pp. 1–29. [CrossRef]
Goncalves, M. , Cardoso, C. , and Badke-Schaub, P. , 2012, “ Find Your Inspiration: Exploring Different Levels of Abstraction in Textual Stimuli,” Second International Conference on Design Creativity, Glasgow, UK.
Bonnardel, N. , and Marmeche, E. , 2005, “ Towards Supporting Evocation Processes in Creative Design: A Cognitive Approach,” Int. J. Hum.-Comput. Stud., 63(4–5), pp. 422–435. [CrossRef]
Acar, S. , and Runco, M. A. , 2014, “ Assessing Associative Distance Among Ideas Elicited by Tests of Divergent Thinking,” Creat. Res. J., 26(2), pp. 229–238. [CrossRef]
McCoy, J. M. , and Evans, G. W. , 2002, “ The Potential Role of the Physical Environment in Fostering Creativity,” Creat. Res. J., 14(3–4), pp. 409–426. [CrossRef]
Goldschmidt, G. , and Weil, M. , 1998, “ Contents and Structure in Design Reasoning,” Des. Issues, 14(3), pp. 85–100. [CrossRef]
Xiong, Y. , Li, Y. , Ma, G. L. , and Pu, J. , 2010, “ Product Form Design Based on the Sketch Cognitive Analysis,” Comput. Integr. Manuf. Syst., 16(7), pp. 1354–1362 (in Chinese).


Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 2

Time allocation of the experiment

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 1

Vertical-shape transformations in a design family [17]

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 3

All sketches of E1

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 4

Per capita occurrences of cognitive actions in each group (black lines at the top are error bars)

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 5

Generation numbers (per capita) of three association types for three participant groups (black lines at the top are error bars)

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 6

Occurrence numbers of actions PF, PS, and FP (per capita) for three association types and three groups (black lines at the top are error bars)



Some tools below are only available to our subscribers or users with an online account.

Related Content

Customize your page view by dragging and repositioning the boxes below.

Related Journal Articles
Related eBook Content
Topic Collections

Sorry! You do not have access to this content. For assistance or to subscribe, please contact us:

  • TELEPHONE: 1-800-843-2763 (Toll-free in the USA)
  • EMAIL: asmedigitalcollection@asme.org
Sign In