Research Papers: Design Theory and Methodology

An Exploratory Study of the Discovery and Selection of Design Methods in Practice

[+] Author and Article Information
Kilian Gericke

Engineering Design and Methodology,
University of Luxembourg,
6, rue Richard Coudenhove Kalergi,
Luxembourg City L-1359, Luxembourg
e-mail: kilian.gericke@uni.lu

Julia Kramer

Berkeley Institute of Design,
University of California, Berkeley,
354/360 Hearst Memorial Mining Building,
Berkeley, CA 94720-1760
e-mail: j.kramer@berkeley.edu

Celeste Roschuni

Berkeley Institute of Design,
University of California, Berkeley,
230 Hesse Hall,
Berkeley, CA 94720-1760
e-mail: celery@berkeley.edu

1Corresponding author.

Contributed by the Design Theory and Methodology Committee of ASME for publication in the JOURNAL OF MECHANICAL DESIGN. Manuscript received January 28, 2016; final manuscript received June 18, 2016; published online August 30, 2016. Assoc. Editor: Mathew I. Campbell.

J. Mech. Des 138(10), 101109 (Aug 30, 2016) (10 pages) Paper No: MD-16-1081; doi: 10.1115/1.4034088 History: Received January 28, 2016; Revised June 18, 2016

This work seeks to understand how design practitioners discover, select, and adapt design methods and methodologies. Design methods and methodologies are mainly used for educational purposes and are not formally transferred into design practice and industry. This prevents design practitioners from accessing the rich body of research and knowledge posed by academia. Various web platforms and textbooks allow users to discover or search for design methods, but little support is provided to assess whether or not a method is appropriate for the context or the task at hand. In this exploratory study, interviews were conducted with practicing engineers and designers. Interview responses were coded and analyzed in an effort to understand the patterns in searching, selecting, assessing, and exchanging experiences with peers in professional practice. This analysis showed that interviewees would like to search for design methods based on their desired outcomes. Additionally, interviewees considered their personal contacts to be the most valuable source of new methods. These insights show that web-based communities of practice may be a potential link between academia and industry, but existing web repositories and communities require further development in order to better meet the needs of the design practitioner community.

Copyright © 2016 by ASME
Your Session has timed out. Please sign back in to continue.


Wallace, K. , 2011, “ Tranferring Design Methods Into Practice,” The Future of Design Methodology, H. Birkhofer , ed., Springer, London, pp. 239–248.
Chakrabarti, A. , and Lindemann, U. , eds., 2016, Impact of Design Research on Industrial Practice, Springer, Cham, Switzerland.
Horvath, I. , 2001, “ A Contemporary Survey of Scientific Research Into Engineering Design,” 13th International Conference on Engineering Design ICED’01, The Design Society, pp. 13–20.
Charter, M. , and Chick, A. , 1997, “ Editorial of the Journal of Sustainable Product Design,” J. Sustainable Prod. Des., 1(1), pp. 5–6.
McAloone, T. C. , and Andreasen, M. M. , 2004, “ Design for Utility, Sustainability and Societal Virtues: Developing Product Service Systems,” 8th International Design Conference—Design 2004, The Design Society, pp. 1545–1552.
Tomiyama, T. , and Meijer, B. R. , 2006, “ Directions of Next Generation Product Development,” Advances in Design, H. ElMaraghy , and W. H. ElMaraghy , eds., Springer, London, pp. 27–35.
Franke, H. , and Deimel, M. , 2004, “ Selecting and Combining Methods for Complex Problem Solving Within the Design Process,” 8th International Design Conference—Design 2004, The Design Society.
Ernzer, M. , and Birkhofer, H. , 2002, “ Selecting Methods for Life Cycle Design Based on the Needs of a Company,” 7th International Design Conference—Design 2002, The Design Society, pp. 1305–1310.
Braun, T. , and Lindemann, U. , 2003, “ Supporting the Selection, Adaptation and Application of Methods in Product Development,” 14th International Conference on Engineering Design ICED’03, The Design Society, pp. 629–630.
López-Mesa, B. , and Thompson, G. , 2003, “ Exploring the Need for an Interactive Software Tool for the Appropriate Selection of Design Methods,” 14th International Conference on Engineering Design ICED’03, The Design Society, pp. 627–628.
López-Mesa, B. , and Bylund, N. , 2010, “ A Study of the Use of Concept Selection Methods From Inside a Company,” Res. Eng. Des., 22(1), pp. 7–27. [CrossRef]
Roozenburg, N. F. M. , and Eekels, J. , 1995, Product Design: Fundamentals and Methods, Wiley, Chichester, UK.
Newell, A. , 1983, “ The Heuristic of George Polya and Its Relation to Artificial Intelligence,” Methods of Heuristic, R. Groner , M. Groner , and W. F. Bischof , eds., Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers, London, pp. 203–204.
Pahl, G. , Beitz, W. , Feldhusen, J. , and Grote, K.-H. , 2006, Konstruktionslehre Grundlagen Erfolgreicher Produktentwicklung, Methoden und Anwendung, 7th ed., Springer, Berlin.
Pahl, G. , Beitz, W. , Feldhusen, J. , and Grote, K. H. , 2007, Engineering Design—A Systematic Approach, 3rd ed., Springer, Berlin.
Hubka, V. , and Eder, W. E. , 1988, Theory of Technical Systems: A Total Concept Theory for Engineering Design, Springer, Berlin.
French, M. J. , 1999, Conceptual Design for Engineers, 3rd ed., Springer, London.
Cross, N. , 2008, Engineering Design Methods, 3rd ed., Wiley, Chichester, UK.
Pugh, S. , 1991, Total Design: Integrated Methods for Successful Product Engineering, Addison-Wesley, Wokingham, UK.
Ullman, D. G. , 2010, The Mechanical Design Process, 4th ed., McGraw-Hill, Boston, MA.
Dym, C. L. , Little, P. , and Orwin, E. J. , 2009, Engineering Design: A Project-Based Introduction, 3rd ed., Wiley, Hoboken, NJ.
Ulrich, K. T. , and Eppinger, S. D. , 2008, Product Design and Development, 4th ed., McGraw-Hill, New York.
Andreasen, M. M. , and Hein, L. , 2000, Integrated Product Development, Technical University of Denmark, Lyngby, Denmark.
Hales, C. , and Gooch, S. , 2004, Managing Engineering Design, 2nd ed., Springer, London.
Araujo, C. S. , Benedetto, H. , Campello, A. C. , Segre, F. M. , and Wright, I. C. , 1996, “ The Utilization of Product Development Methods: A Survey of UK Industry,” J. Eng. Des., 7(3), pp. 265–277. [CrossRef]
Birkhofer, H. , Kloberdanz, H. , Sauer, T. , and Berger, B. , 2002, “ Why Methods Don't Work and How to Get Them to Work,” 3rd International Workshop—Engineering Design and Integrated Product Development EDIProD 2002, pp. 29–36.
Jänsch, J. , 2007, “ Akzeptanz und Anwendung von Konstruktionsmethoden im industriellen Einsatz—Analyse und Empfehlungen aus Kognitionswissenschaftlicher Sicht,” Ph.D. thesis, TU Darmstadt, Darmstadt, Germany.
Geis, C. , Bierhals, R. , Schuster, I. , Badke-Schaub, P. , and Birkhofer, H. , 2008, “ Methods in Practice—A Study on Requirements for Development and Transfer of Design Methods,” 10th International Design Conference—Design 2008, The Design Society, pp. 369–376.
Tomiyama, T. , Gu, P. , Jin, Y. , Lutters, D. , Kind, C. , and Kimura, F. , 2009, “ Design Methodologies: Industrial and Educational Applications,” CIRP Ann. Manuf. Technol., 58(2), pp. 543–565. [CrossRef]
Jagtap, S. , Warell, A. , Hiort, V. , Motte, D. , and Larsson, A. , 2014, “ Design Methods and Factors Influencing Their Uptake in Product Development Companies: A Review,” 13th International Design Conference—Design 2014, The Design Society, pp. 231–240.
Eckert, C. M. , and Clarkson, P. J. , 2005, “ The Reality of Design,” Design Process Improvement: A Review of Current Practice, P. J. Clarkson , and C. M. Eckert , eds., Springer, London, pp. 1–29.
Andreasen, M. M. , 2011, “ 45 Years With Design Methodology,” J. Eng. Des., 22(5), pp. 293–332. [CrossRef]
Gollwitzer, P. M. , 1990, “ Action Phases and Mind-Sets,” Handbook of Motivation and Cognition—Foundations of Social Behaviour, E. T. Higgins , and R. M. Sorrentino , eds., The Guilford Press, London, pp. 53–92.
Gibson, J. J. , 1941, “ A Critical Review of the Concept of Set in Contemporary Experimental Psychology,” Psychol. Bull., 38(9), pp. 781–817. [CrossRef]
Hamilton, R. , Vohs, K. D. , Sellier, A.-L. , and Meyvis, T. , 2011, “ Being of Two Minds: Switching Mindsets Exhausts Self-Regulatory Resources,” Organ. Behav. Hum. Decis. Process., 115(1), pp. 13–24. [CrossRef]
Andreasen, M. M. , 2013, personal communication.
Jones, J. C. , 1992, Design Methods, 2nd ed., Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York.
Cross, N. , 2008, “ The Design Process,” Engineering Design Methods: Strategies for Product Design, 4th ed., Wiley, Chichester, UK, p. 230.
Ertas, A. , and Jones, J. C. , 1993, The Engineering Design Process, Wiley, New York.
Van Gundy, A. B. , 1988, Techniques of Structured Problem Solving, 2nd ed., Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York.
Franke, H.-J. , Löffler, S. , and Deimel, M. , 2003, “ The Database Methods Assists an Effective Application of Design Methods,” 13th International Conference on Engineering Design ICED'03, The Design Society, Glasgow, pp. 155–156.
Lehrstuhl für Produktentwicklung TU München, 2008, “ CiDaD—Competence in Design,” accessed Mar. 2016, http://www.cidad.de/portal/
D. Spath, C. Dill, and M. Scharer, eds., 2001. Vom Markt zum Produkt, Log_X Verlag, Stuttgart, Germany.
DesignExchange, 2016, “ Collaborative Research: TheDesignExchange, an Interactive Portal for the Design Community of Practice,” accessed Mar. 2016, https://www.thedesignexchange.org
Davies, U. , and Wilson, K. , 2011, “ Design Methods for Developing Services,” Design Council, London.
TU Delft, 2015, “ Delft Design Guide,” Wikid, accessed Mar. 2016, http://www.wikid.eu/index.php/Delft_Design_Guide
Gericke, K. , Adolphy, S. , Qureshi, A. J. , Blessing, L. , and Stark, R. , 2013, “ Opening Up Design Methodology,” International Workshop on the Future of Trans-Disciplinary Design 2013, Luxembourg City, Luxembourg, pp. 4–15.
Daalhuizen, J. , Badke-Schaub, P. , and Fokker, J. , 2008, “ Community Based Design Support,” TMCE 2008, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands.
Adar, E. , and Hubermann, B. A. , 2000, “ Free Riding on Gnutella,” First Monday, 5(10), pp. 1–10. [CrossRef]
De Valck, K. , 2005, Virtual Communities of Consumption: Networks of Consumer Knowledge and Companionship, Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Davenport, T. H. , De Long, D. W. , and Beers, M. C. , 1997, “ Building Successful Knowledge Management Projects,” Ernst & Young LLP, London, Center for Business Innovation— Working Paper.
Wenger, E. , 2005, “ Communities of Practice: A Brief Introduction,” Etienne, accessed Mar. 2016, http://wenger-trayner.com/introduction-to-communities-of-practice/
Hew, K. F. , and Hara, N. , 2006, “ Identifying Factors That Encoruage and Hinder Knowledge Sharing in a Longstanding Online Community of Practice,” J. Interact. Online Learn., 5(3), pp. 297–316.
Cambridge, D. , Kaplan, S. , and Suter, V. , 2005, “ Community of Practice Design Guide,” Educause, accessed Mar. 2016, https://net.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/nli0531.pdf
Roschuni, C. , Agogino, A. , and Beckman, S. L. , 2011, “ Supporting the Design Community of Practice,” 18th International Conference on Engineering Design ICED’11, The Design Society, pp. 255–264.
Strasser, C. , and Grösel, B. , 2004, “ A Landscape of Methods—A Practical Approach to Support Method Use in Industry,” 8th International Design Conference—Design 2004, The Design Society, pp. 1167–1172.
Nomaguchi, Y. , Askhoj, A. , Madsen, K. F. , Akai, R. , and Fujita, K. , 2012, “ Design Method Selection Matrix for Facilitating Product Platform and Family Design,” ASME Paper No. DETC2012-70861.
Birkhofer, H. , 2008, “ Tidy Up Design Methods—An Approach Using Elementary Design Methods,” 10th International Design Conference—Design 2008, The Design Society, pp. 1–8.
Zier, S. , Bohn, A. , and Birkhöfer, H. , 2012, “ Investigating Elementary Design Methods: Using the Genome Approach for Creating Complete and Adaptable Method Descriptions,” 12th International Design Conference—Design 2004, The Design Society, pp. 1215–1224.
Ponn, J. , and Lindemann, U. , 2006, “ CiDaD—A Method Portal for Product Development,” 9th International Design Conference—Design 2004, The Design Society, pp. 1221–1228.
Berners-Lee, T. I. M. , Hendler, J. , and Lassila, O. , 2001, “ The Semantic Web,” Sci. Am., 284(5), pp. 34–43. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Resnick, P. , and Varian, H. R. , 1997, “ Recommender Systems,” Commun. ACM, 40(3), pp. 56–58. [CrossRef]
Fuge, M. , Peters, B. , and Agogino, A. , 2014, “ Machine Learning Algorithms for Recommending Design Methods,” ASME J. Mech. Des., 136(10), p. 101103. [CrossRef]
Adomavicius, G. , and Tuzhilin, A. , 2005, “ Toward the Next Generation of Recommender Systems: A Survey of the State-of-the-Art and Possible Extensions,” IEEE Trans. Knowl. Data Eng., 17(6), pp. 734–749. [CrossRef]
Gericke, K. , Meißner, M. , and Paetzold, K. , 2013, “ Understanding the Context of Product Development,” 19th International Conference on Engineering Design ICED’13, The Design Society, Seoul, Korea, Aug. 19–22, pp. 191–200.
Baccarini, D. , 1999, “ The Logical Framework Method for Defining Project Success,” Proj. Manage. J., 30(4), pp. 25–32.
Blessing, L. , and Chakrabarti, A. , 2009, DRM: A Design Research Methodology, Springer, London.


Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 1

Transfer of knowledge between academia and industry



Some tools below are only available to our subscribers or users with an online account.

Related Content

Customize your page view by dragging and repositioning the boxes below.

Related Journal Articles
Related eBook Content
Topic Collections

Sorry! You do not have access to this content. For assistance or to subscribe, please contact us:

  • TELEPHONE: 1-800-843-2763 (Toll-free in the USA)
  • EMAIL: asmedigitalcollection@asme.org
Sign In