Research Papers: Design for Manufacture and the Life Cycle

Modeling the Time-Varying Advantages of a Remanufactured Product: Is “Reman” Better Than “Brand New”?1

[+] Author and Article Information
Minjung Kwak

Assistant Professor
Department of Industrial and
Information Systems Engineering,
Soongsil University,
369 Sangdo-ro, Dongjak-gu,
Seoul 156-743, South Korea

Harrison Kim

Associate Professor
Department of Industrial and
Enterprise Systems Engineering,
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign,
117 Transportation Building,
104 S. Mathews Avenue,
Urbana, IL 61801
e-mail: hmkim@illinois.edu

2Corresponding author.

Contributed by the Design for Manufacturing Committee of ASME for publication in the JOURNAL OF MECHANICAL DESIGN. Manuscript received November 13, 2014; final manuscript received February 3, 2016; published online March 11, 2016. Assoc. Editor: Gul E. Okudan Kremer.

J. Mech. Des 138(5), 051701 (Mar 11, 2016) (18 pages) Paper No: MD-14-1736; doi: 10.1115/1.4032808 History: Received November 13, 2014; Revised February 03, 2016

In order for remanufacturers to succeed in the market, it is important for them to be capable of ensuring in advance that a product is suitable for remanufacturing and that a remanufactured product will provide greater economic and environmental value than a brand-new product. This paper provides an approach to estimate the economic and environmental advantages of a remanufactured product. Focusing on the fact that advantages are greatly influenced by the nature of a product (i.e., its design and lifetime characteristics) as well as the timing of the remanufacturing, this paper proposes a model for assessing the time-varying advantages of remanufacturing a given product. The model provides an objective, quantitative method to compare a remanufactured product with an equivalent brand-new version of the product. Focus is placed on three perspectives: unit production cost, environmental impact, and net profit. By providing a multidimensional assessment tool for measuring product remanufacturability, the model is expected to assist remanufacturers make informed and effective decisions concerning product planning. It also helps marketing activities by supporting an effective sustainability communication with customers. Two versions of the model are presented, each of which targets a specific product type: (1) a product with only physical deterioration and (2) a product with both physical deterioration and technological obsolescence. Each version of the model is illustrated by utilizing an automotive alternator and a desktop computer, respectively.

Copyright © 2016 by ASME
Your Session has timed out. Please sign back in to continue.


Kwak, M. , 2012, “ Green Profit Design for Lifecycle,” Ph.D. dissertation, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, IL.
Kwak, M. , and Kim, H. , 2015, “ Assessing Time-Varying Advantages of Remanufacturing: A Model for Products With Physical and Technological Obsolescence,” 20th International Conference on Engineering Design (ICED15), Milan, Italy, July 27–30, pp. 135–144.
Kwak, M. , and Kim, H. M. , 2011, “ Time-Varying Value of an End-of-Life Product for Design for Recovery,” 18th International Conference on Engineering Design (ICED11), Copenhagen, Denmark, Aug. 15–19, pp. 70–80.
Hauser, W. , and Lund, R. T. , 2003, “ The Remanufacturing Industry: Anatomy of a Giant,” Boston University, Boston, MA.
Fleischmann, M. , Bloemhof-Ruwaard, J. M. , Dekker, R. , van der Laan, E. , van Nunen, J. , and Van Wassenhove, L. N. , 1997, “ Quantitative Models for Reverse Logistics: A Review,” Eur. J. Oper. Res., 103(1), pp. 1–17. [CrossRef]
Seitz, M. A. , 2007, “ A Critical Assessment of Motives for Product Recovery: The Case of Engine Remanufacturing,” J. Cleaner Prod., 15(11–12), pp. 1147–1157. [CrossRef]
Bhuie, A. K. , Ogunseitan, O. A. , Saphores, J.-D. M. , and Shapiro, A. A. , 2004, “ Environmental and Economic Trade-Offs in Consumer Electronic Products Recycling: A Case Study of Cell Phones and Computers,” IEEE International Symposium on Electronics and the Environment, May 10–13, pp. 74–79.
Guide, V. D. R. , Teunter, R. H. , and Van Wassenhove, L. N. , 2003, “ Matching Demand and Supply to Maximize Profits From Remanufacturing,” Manuf. Serv. Oper. Manage., 5(4), pp. 303–316.
Intlekofer, K. , Bras, B. , and Ferguson, M. , 2010, “ Energy Implications of Product Leasing,” Environ. Sci. Technol., 44(12), pp. 4409–4415. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Boustani, A. , Sahni, S. , Graves, S. C. , and Gutowski, T. G. , 2010, “ Appliance Remanufacturing and Life Cycle Energy and Economic Savings,” IEEE International Symposium on Sustainable Systems and Technology (ISSST), Arlington, VA, May 17–19.
Gutowski, T. G. , Sahni, S. , Boustani, A. , and Graves, S. C. , 2011, “ Remanufacturing and Energy Savings,” Environ. Sci. Technol., 45(10), pp. 4540–4547. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Lund, R. T. , 1984, “Remanufacturing: The Experience of the United States and Implications for Developing Countries,” The World Bank, Washington DC.
Guide, V. D. R. , 2000, “ Production Planning and Control for Remanufacturing: Industry Practice and Research Needs,” J. Oper. Manage., 18(4), pp. 467–483. [CrossRef]
Amezquita, T. , Hammond, R. , Salazar, M. , and Bras, B. , 1995, “ Characterizing the Remanufacturability of Engineering Systems,” 1995 ASME Advances in Design Automation Conference, Boston, MA, Sept. 17–20, pp. 271–278.
Hammond, R. , and Bras, B. A. , 1996, “ Design for Remanufacturing Metrics,” 1st International Workshop on Reuse, Eindhoven, The Netherlands, pp. 5–22.
Shu, L. H. , and Flowers, W. C. , 1999, “ Application of a Design-for-Remanufacture Framework to the Selection of Product Life-Cycle Fastening and Joining Methods,” Rob. Comput.-Integr. Manuf., 15(3), pp. 179–190. [CrossRef]
Zwolinski, P. , and Brissaud, D. , 2008, “ Remanufacturing Strategies to Support Product Design and Redesign,” J. Eng. Des., 19(4), pp. 321–335. [CrossRef]
Du, Y. , Cao, H. , Liu, F. , Li, C. , and Chen, X. , 2012, “ An Integrated Method for Evaluating the Remanufacturability of Used Machine Tool,” J. Cleaner Prod., 20(1), pp. 82–91. [CrossRef]
Fang, H. C. , Ong, S. K. , and Nee, A. Y. C. , 2014, “ Product Remanufacturability Assessment Based on Design Information,” Procedia CIRP, 15(0), pp. 195–200. [CrossRef]
Xing, K. , and Luong, L. , 2009, “ Modeling and Evaluation of Product Fitness for Service Life Extension,” J. Eng. Des., 20(3), pp. 243–263. [CrossRef]
Ishii, K. , 1999, “ Incorporating End-of-Life Strategy in Product Definition,” 1st International Symposium on Environmentally Conscious Design and Inverse Manufacturing EcoDesign’99, Tokyo, Japan, Feb. 1–3, pp. 364–369.
Kwak, M. , and Kim, H. M. , 2010, “ Evaluating End-of-Life Recovery Profit by a Simultaneous Consideration of Product Design and Recovery Network Design,” ASME J. Mech. Des., 132(7), p. 071001. [CrossRef]
Kwak, M. , and Kim, H. M. , 2010, “ Assessing Product Family Design From an End-of-Life Perspective,” Eng. Optim., 43(3), pp. 233–255. [CrossRef]
Bras, B. , 2007, “ Design for Remanufacturing Processes,” Environmentally Conscious Mechanical Design, M. Kutz , ed., Wiley, Hoboken, NJ, pp. 283–318.
Kumar, V. , Shirodkar, S. , Camelio, J. A. , and Sutherland, J. W. , 2007, “ Value Flow Characterization During Product Lifecycle to Assist in Recovery Decisions,” Int. J. Prod. Res., 45(18), pp. 4555–4572. [CrossRef]
Rachaniotis, N. P. , and Pappis, C. P. , 2008, “ Preventive Maintenance and Upgrade System: Optimizing the Whole Performance System by Components' Replacement or Rearrangement,” Int. J. Prod. Econ., 112(1), pp. 236–244. [CrossRef]
Pandey, V. , and Thurston, D. , 2009, “ Effective Age of Remanufactured Products: An Entropy Approach,” ASME J. Mech. Des., 131(3), p. 031008. [CrossRef]
Guide, V. D. R. , Souza, G. C. , Van Wassenhove, L. N. , and Blackburn, J. D. , 2006, “ Time Value of Commercial Product Returns,” Manage. Sci., 52(8), pp. 1200–1214. [CrossRef]
Ferrer, G. , 1997, “ The Economics of Personal Computer Remanufacturing,” Resour., Conserv. Recycl., 21(2), pp. 79–108. [CrossRef]
Ishigami, Y. , Yagi, H. , Kondoh, S. , Umeda, Y. , Shimomura, Y. , and Yoshioka, M. , 2003, “ Development of a Design Methodology for Upgradability Involving Changes of Functions,” EcoDesign’03, Tokyo, Japan, Dec. 8–11, pp. 235–242.
Kwak, M. , Kim, L. , Sarvana, O. , Kim, H. M. , Finamore, P. , and Hazewinkel, H. , 2012, “ Life Cycle Assessment of Complex Heavy Duty Off-Road Equipment,” ASME Paper No. DETC2012-70547.
Rebitzer, G. , Ekvall, T. , Frischknecht, R. , Hunkeler, D. , Norris, G. , Rydberg, T. , Schmidt, W.-P. , Suh, S. , Weidema, B. P. , and Pennington, D. W. , 2004, “ Life Cycle Assessment: Part 1: Framework, Goal and Scope Definition, Inventory Analysis, and Applications,” Environ. Int., 30(5), pp. 701–720. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Smith, V. M. , and Keoleian, G. A. , 2004, “ The Value of Remanufactured Engines: Life-Cycle Environmental and Economic Perspectives,” J. Ind. Ecol., 8(1–2), pp. 193–221.
Goldey, C. L. , Kuester, E. , Mummert, R. , Okrasinski, T. A. , Olson, D. , and Schaeffer, W. J. , 2010, “ Lifecycle Assessment of the Environmental Benefits of Remanufactured Product Within a ‘Green’ Supply Chain,” IEEE International Symposium on Sustainable Systems and Technology, Washington DC, May 17–19.
Umeda, Y. , Kondoh, S. , and Sugino, T. , 2006, “ Analysis of Reusability Using Marginal Reuse Rate,” Ann. CIRP-Manuf. Technol., 55(1), pp. 41–44. [CrossRef]
Geyer, R. , and Jackson, T. , 2004, “ Supply Loops and Their Constraints: The Industrial Ecology of Recycling and Reuse,” Calif. Manage. Rev., 46(2), pp. 55–73. [CrossRef]
Guide, V. D. R. , and Li, J. , 2010, “ The Potential for Cannibalization of New Products Sales by Remanufactured Products,” Decis. Sci., 41(3), pp. 547–572. [CrossRef]
Thomas, V. M. , 2003, “ Demand and Dematerialization Impacts of Second-Hand Markets: Reuse or More Use?,” J. Ind. Ecol., 7(2), pp. 65–78. [CrossRef]
Ferguson, M. E. , and Toktay, L. B. , 2006, “ The Effect of Competition on Recovery Strategies,” Prod. Oper. Manage., 15(3), pp. 351–368. [CrossRef]
Abbey, J. D. , Meloy, M. G. , Guide, V. D. R. , and Atalay, S. , 2015, “ Remanufactured Products in Closed-Loop Supply Chains for Consumer Goods,” Prod. Oper. Manage., 24(3), pp. 488–503. [CrossRef]
Ovchinnikov, A. , 2011, “ Revenue and Cost Management for Remanufactured Products,” Prod. Oper. Manage., 20(6), pp. 824–840. [CrossRef]
Ovchinnikov, A. , Blass, V. , and Raz, G. , 2014, “ Economic and Environmental Assessment of Remanufacturing Strategies for Product + Service Firms,” Prod. Oper. Manage., 23(5), pp. 744–761. [CrossRef]
Guide, V. D. R. , and Van Wassenhove, L. N. , 2001, “ Managing Product Returns for Remanufacturing,” Prod. Oper. Manage., 10(2), pp. 142–155. [CrossRef]
Klausner, M. , and Hendrickson, C. T. , 2000, “ Reverse-Logistics Strategy for Product Take-Back,” Interfaces, 30(3), pp. 156–165. [CrossRef]
Liang, Y. , Pokharel, S. , and Lim, G. H. , 2009, “ Pricing Used Products for Remanufacturing,” Eur. J. Oper. Res., 193(2), pp. 390–395. [CrossRef]
Vadde, S. , Kamarthi, S. V. , and Gupta, S. M. , 2007, “ Optimal Pricing of Reusable and Recyclable Components Under Alternative Product Acquisition Mechanisms,” Int. J. Prod. Res., 45(18–19), pp. 4621–4652. [CrossRef]
Mitra, S. , 2007, “ Revenue Management for Remanufactured Products,” Omega, 35(5), pp. 553–562. [CrossRef]
Kwak, M. , and Kim, H. , 2013, “ Market Positioning of Remanufactured Products With Optimal Planning for Part Upgrades,” ASME J. Mech. Des., 135(1), p. 011007. [CrossRef]
Vadde, S. , Zeid, A. , and Kamarthi, S. V. , 2011, “ Pricing Decisions in a Multi-Criteria Setting for Product Recovery Facilities,” Omega, 39(2), pp. 186–193. [CrossRef]
Vorasayan, J. , and Ryan, S. M. , 2006, “ Optimal Price and Quantity of Refurbished Products,” Prod. Oper. Manage., 15(3), pp. 369–383. [CrossRef]
Atasu, A. , Sarvary, M. , and Wassenhove, L. N. V. , 2008, “ Remanufacturing as a Marketing Strategy,” Manage. Sci., 54(10), pp. 1731–1746. [CrossRef]
Debo, L. G. , Toktay, L. B. , and Wassenhove, L. N. V. , 2005, “ Market Segmentation and Product Technology Selection for Remanufacturable Products,” Manage. Sci., 51(8), pp. 1193–1205. [CrossRef]
Wu, C.-H. , 2012, “ Product-Design and Pricing Strategies With Remanufacturing,” Eur. J. Oper. Res., 222(2), pp. 204–215. [CrossRef]
Mangun, D. , and Thurston, D. L. , 2002, “ Incorporating Component Reuse, Remanufacture, and Recycle Into Product Portfolio Design,” IEEE Trans. Eng. Manage., 49(4), pp. 479–490. [CrossRef]
Jayaraman, V. , 2006, “ Production Planning for Closed-Loop Supply Chains With Product Recovery and Reuse: An Analytical Approach,” Int. J. Prod. Res., 44(5), pp. 981–998. [CrossRef]
Franke, C. , Basdere, B. , Ciupek, M. , and Seliger, S. , 2006, “ Remanufacturing of Mobile Phones—Capacity, Program and Facility Adaptation Planning,” Omega, 34(6), pp. 562–570. [CrossRef]
Parker, D. , and Butler, P. , 2007, “An Introduction to Remanufacturing,” Centre for Remanufacturing & Reuse, Aylesbury, UK, last accessed Nov. 6, 2012.
Rose, C. M. , Ishii, K. , and Stevels, A. , 2002, “ Influencing Design to Improve Product End-of-Life Stage,” Res. Eng. Des., 13(2), pp. 83–93.
Cade, W. , (Founder of PC Rebuilders & Recyclers), 2009, personal communication.
Atasu, A. , Guide, D. R. , and Wassenhove, L. N. V. , 2010, “ So What If Remanufacturing Cannibalizes My New Product Sales?,” Calif. Manage. Rev., 52(2), pp. 56–76. [CrossRef]
Schau, E. , Traverso, M. , and Finkbeiner, M. , 2012, “ Life Cycle Approach to Sustainability Assessment: A Case Study of Remanufactured Alternators,” J. Remanufacturing., 2(1), pp. 1–14. [CrossRef]
Anityasari, M. , and Kaebernick, H. , 2008, “ A Concept of Reliability Evaluation for Reuse and Remanufacturing,” Int. J. Sustainable Manuf., 1(1/2), pp. 3–17. [CrossRef]
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, “ National Compensation Survey,” http://www.bls.gov/ncs/ocs/sp/nctb1476.pdf
Painton, L. , and Campbell, J. , 1995, “ Genetic Algorithms in Optimization of System Reliability,” IEEE Trans. Reliab., 44(2), pp. 172–195. [CrossRef]
Microsoft, 2008, “ The Enterprise PC Lifecycle,” Microsoft Corporation, Redmond, WA.
Dell, “Client Energy Savings Calculator.”
Kwak, M. , Behdad, S. , Zhao, Y. , Kim, H. M. , and Thurston, D. , 2011, “ E-Waste Stream Analysis and Design Implications,” ASME J. Mech. Des., 133(10), p. 101003. [CrossRef]
Ma, J. , Kwak, M. , and Kim, H. M. , 2014, “ Demand Trend Mining for Predictive Life Cycle Design,” J. Cleaner Prod., 68(0), pp. 189–199. [CrossRef]
Tucker, C. S. , and Kim, H. M. , 2011, “ Trending Mining for Predictive Product Design,” ASME J. Mech. Des., 133(11), p. 111008. [CrossRef]
Rutherford, D. P. , and Wilhelm, W. E. , 1999, “ Forecasting Notebook Computer Price as a Function of Constituent Features,” Comput. Ind. Eng., 37(4), pp. 823–845. [CrossRef]
Kwak, M. , Kim, H. M. , and Thurston, D. , 2011, “ Formulating Second-Hand Market Value as a Function of Product Specifications, Age, and Conditions,” ASME J. Mech. Des., 134(3), p. 032001. [CrossRef]


Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 1

Overview of the proposed model

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 2

The cost advantage of the remanufactured alternator

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 3

The environmental advantage of the remanufactured alternator

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 4

The net profit advantage of the remanufactured alternator (β = 0.7)

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 6

The cost advantage of the remanufactured PC

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 8

α* and γ* where the remanufactured and brand-new PCs are equally green

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 11

Sensitivity analysis: change of β* under varied settings for cost parameters

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 12

Increase in the cost advantage when the part physical reusability is improved by 5% point

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 13

Increase in the environmental advantage when the part physical reusability is improved by 5% point

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 5

β* where the remanufactured and brand-new alternators are equally profitable

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 9

The net profit advantage of the remanufactured PC (β = 0.7)

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 10

β* where the remanufactured and brand-new PCs are equally profitable

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 14

Effect of changing the target specifications for the remanufactured product

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 7

The environmental advantage of the remanufactured PC




Some tools below are only available to our subscribers or users with an online account.

Related Content

Customize your page view by dragging and repositioning the boxes below.

Related Journal Articles
Related eBook Content
Topic Collections

Sorry! You do not have access to this content. For assistance or to subscribe, please contact us:

  • TELEPHONE: 1-800-843-2763 (Toll-free in the USA)
  • EMAIL: asmedigitalcollection@asme.org
Sign In